Skip to content
Paid vs social_blog header_1

Mastering the Mix: The Power of Paid Ads and Organic Social Media

Navigating the digital marketing ecosystem can be daunting, especially when deciding where to allocate your budget and efforts between paid ads and organic social posts. While paid ads offer a targeted approach to quickly reach potential customers, organic social posts can foster genuine engagement and build long-term brand loyalty. This blog explores the nuanced differences between these two strategies, offering insights on how to effectively leverage each for digital marketing success.

Social Media Advertising in 2024

According to Forbes, organic reach is declining across almost every social media platform. On Facebook, for example, research shows that just 0.07% of a page’s fans engage with the average organic post. Instagram is also experiencing the same issue with engagement rates falling for the third consecutive year in a row.

What does this mean for social media advertising in 2024?

It is increasingly valuable for brands to invest in a hybrid social media strategy that invests in paid social media ads alongside organic posts to expand brands’ reach.

Following the increasing value of social media ads, social media advertising spend is set to reach $219.8 billion in 2024. This will account for almost 30% of total global digital advertising spend.

Paid Social Media Ads vs. Organic Social Posts

What’s the difference between paid social ads and their organic counterparts?

In many ways, paid ads enable precision and instant impact. With paid advertising, brands can take a laser-focused approach, where every dollar spent works to target a brand’s audience through detailed demographics, interests, and/or behaviors. This drives immediate results such as conversions, leads, or sales.

On the other hand, with organic social posts, marketers take a more long-term approach to nurture, engage, and build a community around their brand. This long-term brand building can establish credibility, and foster genuine connections with their audience.

While paid ads offer the speed and specificity to reach a brand’s audience directly, organic social posts lay down the foundation of a brand's identity, voice, and values. Ideally, they work in harmony, creating a dynamic social media strategy that leverages the immediate impact of paid advertising alongside the grassroots engagement of organic content.

Benefits of Paid Ads

While organic social media nurtures brand-community relationships, paid ads offer a powerful tool for reaching specific objectives with precision and speed. Here are the advantages of incorporating paid social media posts into your advertising strategy:

  • Targeted Advertising: One of the greatest strengths of paid social is the ability to target ads based on detailed demographics, interests, behaviors, and more. This precision targeting ensures that your marketing budget is being spent efficiently, reaching only the people most likely to convert.
  • Measurable ROI: Paid ad campaigns come with robust analytics and tracking capabilities, allowing marketers to measure their return on investment in real-time. This data-driven approach enables ongoing optimization of campaigns for better performance.
  • Speed and Agility: Paid advertising campaigns can be launched quickly, providing the agility to respond to market trends, promotional opportunities, or competitive actions. This speed is invaluable for capitalizing on time-sensitive opportunities.
  • Enhanced Content Visibility: With the decline in organic reach on many platforms, paid ads ensure that your content is seen. Whether it's promoting a new product launch, a special offer, or a piece of high-value content, paid ads boost visibility and engagement.

What Makes a Great Paid Ad 

For a paid ad to have a high engagement rate in terms of creative design, key aspects to consider include:

  1. Visual Appeal: Eye-catching visuals, vibrant colors, and high-quality images or videos can capture attention and encourage interaction. The use of interactive ad formats that capture and keep attention
  2. Compelling Copy: Clear, concise, and persuasive ad copy that conveys your brand’s product or service effectively and prompts action can drive engagement.
  3. Call-to-Action (CTA): A strong and clear CTA that directs users on what to do next to enhance engagement and drive conversions.
  4. Personalization: Tailoring the ad’s content to the target audience's preferences and needs to make the ad more relevant and engaging.
  5. Storytelling: A narrative or story around the product or service that creates an emotional connection with the audience, increasing engagement.


Benefits of Organic Social Posts

Organic social posts can serve as the backbone of a brand's digital presence, laying the foundation for a vibrant and engaged community. Here are some other benefits of organic social media posting:

  • Authentic Engagement: Organic content fosters genuine interactions between brands and their followers. It allows a brand to communicate its story, values, and personality, creating a loyal community around shared interests.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: One of the most appealing aspects of organic social media is its cost-effectiveness. Without the need for ad spend, brands can consistently engage with their audience, build brand awareness, and support customer service efforts.
  • SEO Benefits: Regularly posting engaging organic content can also have indirect SEO benefits. Social signals, such as likes, shares, and comments, can increase your brand's online visibility and drive traffic to your website.
  • Customer Insights: Engaging with your audience through organic posts provides valuable insights into their preferences and behavior. These interactions can inform your broader marketing strategy, from product development to targeted advertising campaigns.
  • Long-Term Brand Building: Organic social media is essential for long-term brand building. Consistently providing valuable and relevant content can establish your brand as a thought leader in your industry and deepen trust with your audience.

What Makes a Great Organic Social Post

To make an organic social post perform well, it’s crucial to prioritize brand authenticity, engagement, and nurturing connections with your audience. 

Creative Aspects of High-Performing Organic Posts

For an organic social post to have a high engagement rate in terms of creative design, the following aspects are crucial:

  1. Visual Consistency: Maintaining a consistent visual style, theme, and tone across organic posts can help in brand recognition and engagement.
  2. User-Generated Content (UGC): Incorporating UGC can enhance engagement by providing real feedback on your product or service and fostering a sense of community.
  3. Interactive Elements: Including interactive elements like polls, quizzes, or contests can encourage audience participation and boost engagement.
  4. Timely and Relevant Content: Posting content that is timely, relevant, and aligned with current trends or events can encourage sharing and amplify engagement by tapping into viral trends.


Creating a Balanced Approach

Embracing both organic and paid social media allows brands to engage deeply with their existing community while also expanding their reach to new audiences. By carefully crafting a hybrid strategy that leverages the unique benefits of each, brands can achieve a comprehensive, multi-faceted presence that resonates with consumers at every stage of their journey. This balanced approach maximizes the strengths of each method, driving not only immediate results but also a strong, long-lasting presence digitally.

Benefits of a hybrid strategy include:

  • Enhanced Visibility: While organic posts cultivate community and brand identity, paid ads break through social media algorithms, ensuring your message reaches beyond your existing followers.
  • Cost-Efficient Scaling: Leverage the immediate feedback from organic engagement to refine your paid advertising. This ensures your budget is always targeting the most effective audience segments and behaviors.
  • Continuous Engagement: Seamlessly integrate your paid and organic efforts to keep your audience constantly engaged, with fresh content that appeals to both new prospects and loyal customers.
  • Strategic Content Amplification: Identify high-performing organic content and give it a boost with paid promotion, maximizing its reach and impact.


The question isn't whether to choose between paid ads or organic social posts but how to effectively integrate both into a unified social media strategy. By leveraging the strengths of each, brands can maximize their reach, engage their audience more deeply, and drive meaningful results in today's competitive digital landscape.


Ready to harness the power of high-quality paid and organic ads for your brand? 

Contact CRAFTSMAN+ today to explore how our creative design technology can elevate your paid and organic ads, driving unparalleled engagement and growth.